Welcome! I'd choose 2 (and destroy your blood card.) The chances are slim that anything catastrophic will happen in the first place, so you have time to win her over before you hit her with that one.
Go slowly with your wife, and shower with more love, attention and praise than you ever have before.
Enjoy non-"theocratic" activities like museums or parks or whatever you like to do together.
In short, make your wife's "new" husband better than her old cult one.
Best of luck,
BOC